Post by Biblically Accurate Angel on Nov 7, 2017 23:41:44 GMT -5
TGC Thomas
I'm here now!
10:12
Frankthetriviaman
Hi TGC; great to see you
How's it going?
10:12
TGC Thomas
Not much really
could you maybe summarize what happened in 3WSR since I left?
10:14
Frankthetriviaman
A lot, actually. Where do you remember leaving off?
BTW, you still want to do that canon thing we talked about in the PM?
10:14
TGC Thomas
yesh we can do the canon thing
i remember leaving around the time when Thomas and MIB entered the Magic Railroad, or something like that.
10:15
Frankthetriviaman
Ah, ok
Well, the short summary is:
The Magic Railroad plot was resolved, with Lady now working on Sodor
The Numbered Diesels won their trial
We've developed a lot of backgrounds for certain Colormen
The Ulfstead expansion is nearing completion
Diesel 3 has been rescued and is currently getting restored
And there is Some other stuff the other guys can fill you in on better than me
But regarding the canon thing; you suggested we go through every episode and see what is and is not canon?
10:18
TGC Thomas
yeah, we've established that when the TVS and RWS conflict the RWS takes priority
and that the two Christmas episodes of seasons 1 and 2 are canon
10:18
Frankthetriviaman
Correct. But when they "blend" if you will, both are accepted
That being said, I propose that for Seasons 1-4, all episodes are canon, except Rusty to the Rescue
10:19
TGC Thomas
so the next non-RWS episode is the first of season 5. I'll send a link
10:19
Frankthetriviaman
Should we set up a thread?
10:19
TGC Thomas
we probably shoudl
10:20
Frankthetriviaman
I'll put it Under 3WSR discussion; give me a second
I set it up; you see it?
10:23
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'm on mobile so I'm trying to not glitch the chat while switching through tabs
10:24
Frankthetriviaman
No problem; let me know what you think so far
*of the thread
10:24
TGC Thomas
It all seems good, now let's start watching Season 5
10:25
Frankthetriviaman
I'll pull up the wiki page
10:26
TGC Thomas
How about we watch 3 episodes in a row and then give out thoughts, then watch 3 more, ect
10:27
Frankthetriviaman
I watched all of season 5 not too long ago; most of the episodes are fresh in my mind if that helps
if you would rather rewatch them though, I am up for it
10:27
TGC Thomas
Doing this will really help me get back into TTTE, other fandoms have been taking over my mind recently
10:28
Frankthetriviaman
Ok; could you just get me a minute to get my headphones?
10:28
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'll try to find a playlist of season 5 while I'm waiting
10:31
Frankthetriviaman
ok, found them
10:32
TGC Thomas
test
10:32
Frankthetriviaman
Well, I think it makes the most sense to go in chronological order for the season
10:32
TGC Thomas
so, Cranky Bugs is first up I guess
10:33
Frankthetriviaman
Yes, then Horrid Lorry and a better view for Gordon
10:33
TGC Thomas
Ok, so I'm starting the episodes now.
10:33
Frankthetriviaman
*I love how in Cranky Bugs, there's that opening shot of Thomas and Percy, then the camera pans up to show Big Mickey
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:39
Frankthetriviaman
you still there TGC?
10:39
TGC Thomas
Just finished Cranky Bugs, it doesn't seem the best of Season 5, but it's still great nonetheless
I'm sort of wondering how Cranky was able to be just put back up like that
Diesel 11 has joined the chat.
10:41
Frankthetriviaman
There's only so much they can show in 4 1/2 minutes; I think a lot happened off screen
I say we should consider it canon
10:41
TGC Thomas
Same here.
10:41
Frankthetriviaman
On to Horrid Lorry then?
10:41
Diesel 11
Hey guys!
10:42
Frankthetriviaman
Hi D-11; TGC and I are watching season 5 episodes
10:42
TGC Thomas
Hey, were just reviewing Season 5 for our canon debate, were on Horrid Lorry now
10:43
Frankthetriviaman
I got it set up on my end, ready to watch. How about you TGC?
10:43
Diesel 11
Interesting. Can't watch them ATM, but I can give my opinion.
10:43
Frankthetriviaman
Thanks D-11; we can always use the extra voice.
Anyway, ready to start TGC?
10:44
Diesel 11
Are you watching this on TinyChat or something together?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
10:44
Frankthetriviaman
No; we are each watching on our own end
He is on mobile though, so he may periodically leave and come.
I'm watching the episode now; give me three minutes to finish it
10:46
Diesel 11
Ah, I see.
Sure.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:47
TGC Thomas
Just finsih
*finshed Horrid Lorry, it's a great episode, I say it should be canon
10:48
Diesel 11
Agreed.
10:48
Frankthetriviaman
Yes, canon indeed
10:49
TGC Thomas
So, on to ABVFG?
10:49
Frankthetriviaman
I think that solves it quick. Better View for Gordon?
Indeed
Got it set up. Ready to go?
10:50
Diesel 11
It's canon.
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:55
TGC Thomas
Finished, I'd say it's canon
10:55
Frankthetriviaman
agreed
So on to Lady Hatt's Birthday Party, James and the trouble with trees, and Gordon and the Gremlin
10:56
TGC Thomas
So, we'll move onto Lady Hatt's Birthday Party then I'll have to go for 5 minutes or so, I'll be back quick though.
10:57
Frankthetriviaman
Wait, you mean go for 5 min to watch the video, or do other things?
10:57
TGC Thomas
actually I'll have to go now, it will only be 5 minutes though
10:58
Frankthetriviaman
ok; see you soon
10:58
TGC Thomas
*i have to do some other stuff, I mean
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:01
Diesel 11
See ya.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:02
TGC Thomas
I'm back now, didn't take as long as I though
11:03
Frankthetriviaman
It's ok. I just finished with Lady Hatt's Birthday party; you ready to watch it?
11:03
Diesel 11
It's canon.
11:03
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'm starting now
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:07
Diesel 11
Oh yeah, before I forget, have you been reading my TUGS fanfics?
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:08
TGC Thomas
It's fairly good, I consider it canon
I mean the episode
11:09
Diesel 11
My TUGS fanfics?
11:09
TGC Thomas
the chat didn't update
i haven't read the fanfics, I'll have too soon.
11:10
Frankthetriviaman
I skimmed them, but still need to read them in depth
11:10
Diesel 11
It's actually the longest stuff I've ever written... I wouldn't mind hearing your thoughts on them.
11:10
TGC Thomas
so, onto the next episode then?
11:11
Frankthetriviaman
yes
*to both.
So, James and the trouble with trees then?
11:11
Diesel 11
Canon.
11:12
Frankthetriviaman
Actually, there is one thing about this episode that kills it for me...
11:12
Diesel 11
What's that?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:13
Frankthetriviaman
*I'll tell you when TGC gets back
11:13
Diesel 11
The suspense is killing me.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:16
TGC Thomas
Canon
So, what is the thing that irks you, Frank?
11:17
Frankthetriviaman
How could the train have been too heavy for James to go backwards with? He had no problem pulling it in the first place
11:18
TGC Thomas
He was going downhill.
11:18
Diesel 11
Coupled with the rain, it makes sense to me.
11:18
Frankthetriviaman
I'd buy that. We can consider it canon
11:19
TGC Thomas
Gordon and the gremlin is next up
11:19
Diesel 11
Canon.
:
11:20
Frankthetriviaman
Im ready. How about you?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:24
TGC Thomas
Finished, Percy's writing wasn't the best in this episode, but still good
11:25
Frankthetriviaman
Major plot hole though
11:25
TGC Thomas
I Didn't see it.
11:25
Frankthetriviaman
So thomas brought the visitor from the docks to Gordon so Gordon could take her...
to Thomas, who then took her to the ferry.
why?
11:26
TGC Thomas
Didn't think of that,
Lets keep it undecided for now, we can have Toz and Tug give their opinions
11:27
Frankthetriviaman
While it was a good story, that for me, makes me want to argue non-canon. But I agree, let's get some other opinions in on this
D-11, you still there?
11:28
Diesel 11
Hold it, let me read the plot summary and I'll weigh in on my thoughts.
*on, not it.
11:28
Frankthetriviaman
Next is Bye George, Baa and Put Upon Percy
11:29
TGC Thomas
non-related to the argument, but that Ferry at the end seems awfully familiar...
I've watched Bye George recently, I say canon
11:29
Diesel 11
Did they say explicitly that she came from the Docks?
11:30
TGC Thomas
Yes.
11:30
Frankthetriviaman
Ah, the Fulton Ferry from Tugs. It was mentioned in Chapter four of the crossover, but I don't think it will play much of a role, to be honesy
*honest
But it is on Sodor, if we change our minds
11:31
Diesel 11
I only watched it a couple times, so I'll need to rewatch it before I give my full thoughts. However...
Perhaps Sir Topham scheduled a 'pleasure trip' on the ferry?
11:32
Frankthetriviaman
Perhaps, but my point, is, why did Thomas bring her from the docks to Gordon at that station, then Gordon brought her to another station, where Thomas picked her up, to take her to the ferry.
Doesn't make much sense
Though yes, Bye George was good, I say canon on that one too
11:33
TGC Thomas
lets go back to this later, I don't need to watch Bye George since I've watched it many times over before and I say canon, I'll wait for Frank though
11:34
Diesel 11
Canon.
11:34
Frankthetriviaman
That's ok, I'm good. Onto Baa! then?
11:34
TGC Thomas
I guess so! BTW I have to get off in half an hour
11:35
Frankthetriviaman
understood.
11:35
Diesel 11
Baa! = Canon.
Sure thing, TGC.
11:35
Frankthetriviaman
Before you go though, I do want to ask you about Thomas and the Tugs, if that is ok TGC
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:40
TGC Thomas
Yeah that's fine, we can maybe get 1 more episode in, then talk about other stuff,
so Baa is good, I'll say canon
11:41
Frankthetriviaman
Didn't Percy and Toby seem a little out of character at the beginning though?
11:42
Diesel 11
In Baa! ? I don't think so...
11:42
Frankthetriviaman
"The docks are full of fish, not flowers"... seems kinda mean for Toby
11:42
TGC Thomas
Toby was a little bit OOC, but Percy seemed to be fine, just tired
11:43
Frankthetriviaman
fair point. I want it to be canon, but I didn't like that Toby was OOC
Should we make this one undecided too?
11:44
Diesel 11
*Doesn't know what OOC means* *Looks it up* *Calls himself an idiot*
11:44
TGC Thomas
I'll watch the beginning again real quick
11:45
Diesel 11
And I didn't think he was that OOC.
11:45
TGC Thomas
I think Toby was just teasing Percy a little bit
11:46
Frankthetriviaman
Perhaps. Considering he's not as OOC as other appearances though, I think this is ok then. It's canon
11:47
TGC Thomas
Ok, now I have a quick question, are there any Season 5 Episodes that you are particularly not fond of?
11:48
Diesel 11
Nope. All are great.
11:48
Frankthetriviaman
No, not really
So TGC, about Thomas and the Tugs
11:49
TGC Thomas
im listening
11:49
Frankthetriviaman
You still want to work on the Rosie Puffa Geoffrey arc?
Tug and I haven't touched it, didn't want to risk interfering with your plans
11:50
Diesel 11
Yup, and I can swear for them!
11:51
TGC Thomas
it's fine if you try to do some things with it, for the most part just try to remember stuff from the equivalent arc in 3WSR
11:52
Frankthetriviaman
That's just it... we weren't sure where to go with it.
We were wondering if you wanted to write the next part of it
11:52
TGC Thomas
I'll PM you tomorrow about the arc, gonna have to go off in 10 minutes
11:53
Frankthetriviaman
All right; I look forward to hearing back
The problem has been that i've had a bit of a creative rut with the story; haven't had a new chapter in weeks.
Actually, your help in general would be great
11:54
Diesel 11
If you're in a rut, I might be able to come up with something.
11:54
TGC Thomas
So, let's talk about Seasons 6 and 7, are there any episodes of those that you when problems with? I'm trying to speed up the process by just dealing with episodes that are brought up form problems
11:54
Diesel 11
Involving Nantucket...
11:54
Frankthetriviaman
I have four episodes from season 7 that I don't consider canon
11:55
TGC Thomas
Which 4? And are there any from Season 6 you aren't fond of?
11:55
Frankthetriviaman
D-11: I'm willing to consider it. As long as you don't necessarily contradict what we said in chapter three, it should work
The four episodes are:The Old Bridge .Rheneas and the Roller Coaster .Percy Gets It Right .Edward's Brass Band
11:56
Diesel 11
My thoughts are that they were SOLD as scrap, but something popped up before they WERE scrapped. I'm still working it out in my head, but I think it's a better alternative than just scrapping them.
And why do you consider those non-canon?
11:57
TGC Thomas
Those 4 were pretty bad, I agree with Frank
11:57
Frankthetriviaman
The Old Bridge- Skarloey is way out of character
Roller Coaster- The who plot is ridiculous, and Rheneas is out of character
Percy gets it right- Sir Topham Hatt is out of character
Edward's brass band- out of character Edward
11:58
TGC Thomas
as usual
anyways I have to go now
11:59
Frankthetriviaman
Ok, so we'll see you tomorrow then?
Good night TGC
11:59
Diesel 11
Haven't watched EBB or RATRC, but with TOB, anyone can be scared, even a wise old engine like Skarloey. As for PGIR, sometimes people are just busy.
See you, TGC!
11:59
TGC Thomas
Yeah, PM me if I forget to PM you
12:00
Frankthetriviaman
No problem.
So, D-11, if it'll help, let me just remind you what happened in Thomas and the Tugs
12:01
Diesel 11
Big Mickey and Cranky, right?
12:01
Frankthetriviaman
No, I mean regarding Nantucket
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
12:01
Frankthetriviaman
When the great depression hit, in the following months a lot of older vessels were sold for scrap.
12:01
Diesel 11
Oh, sorry. Sure, go ahead.
12:02
Frankthetriviaman
Old Rusty was sold for scrap because he was a derelect tramper that had just been sitting there for years; there was no saving him
Princess Alice was older than Duchess, Vienna and other cruise ships of the era, so the line that owned her sold her for scrap because she was not worth the upkeep.
And Nantucket was sold for scrap because he was an "old dirt bucket" and his owners decided the cost to maintain him was too much
12:04
Diesel 11
I think I could work with that. I'll see what I can do.
Hi Toz!
12:04
Toz76
What did I miss?
12:04
Diesel 11
Canon discussions.
TGC.
And much, much more!
12:05
Frankthetriviaman
I'll copy and paste this to the live chat PM later
Does that help D-11?
I'm here now!
10:12
Frankthetriviaman
Hi TGC; great to see you
How's it going?
10:12
TGC Thomas
Not much really
could you maybe summarize what happened in 3WSR since I left?
10:14
Frankthetriviaman
A lot, actually. Where do you remember leaving off?
BTW, you still want to do that canon thing we talked about in the PM?
10:14
TGC Thomas
yesh we can do the canon thing
i remember leaving around the time when Thomas and MIB entered the Magic Railroad, or something like that.
10:15
Frankthetriviaman
Ah, ok
Well, the short summary is:
The Magic Railroad plot was resolved, with Lady now working on Sodor
The Numbered Diesels won their trial
We've developed a lot of backgrounds for certain Colormen
The Ulfstead expansion is nearing completion
Diesel 3 has been rescued and is currently getting restored
And there is Some other stuff the other guys can fill you in on better than me
But regarding the canon thing; you suggested we go through every episode and see what is and is not canon?
10:18
TGC Thomas
yeah, we've established that when the TVS and RWS conflict the RWS takes priority
and that the two Christmas episodes of seasons 1 and 2 are canon
10:18
Frankthetriviaman
Correct. But when they "blend" if you will, both are accepted
That being said, I propose that for Seasons 1-4, all episodes are canon, except Rusty to the Rescue
10:19
TGC Thomas
so the next non-RWS episode is the first of season 5. I'll send a link
10:19
Frankthetriviaman
Should we set up a thread?
10:19
TGC Thomas
we probably shoudl
10:20
Frankthetriviaman
I'll put it Under 3WSR discussion; give me a second
I set it up; you see it?
10:23
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'm on mobile so I'm trying to not glitch the chat while switching through tabs
10:24
Frankthetriviaman
No problem; let me know what you think so far
*of the thread
10:24
TGC Thomas
It all seems good, now let's start watching Season 5
10:25
Frankthetriviaman
I'll pull up the wiki page
10:26
TGC Thomas
How about we watch 3 episodes in a row and then give out thoughts, then watch 3 more, ect
10:27
Frankthetriviaman
I watched all of season 5 not too long ago; most of the episodes are fresh in my mind if that helps
if you would rather rewatch them though, I am up for it
10:27
TGC Thomas
Doing this will really help me get back into TTTE, other fandoms have been taking over my mind recently
10:28
Frankthetriviaman
Ok; could you just get me a minute to get my headphones?
10:28
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'll try to find a playlist of season 5 while I'm waiting
10:31
Frankthetriviaman
ok, found them
10:32
TGC Thomas
test
10:32
Frankthetriviaman
Well, I think it makes the most sense to go in chronological order for the season
10:32
TGC Thomas
so, Cranky Bugs is first up I guess
10:33
Frankthetriviaman
Yes, then Horrid Lorry and a better view for Gordon
10:33
TGC Thomas
Ok, so I'm starting the episodes now.
10:33
Frankthetriviaman
*I love how in Cranky Bugs, there's that opening shot of Thomas and Percy, then the camera pans up to show Big Mickey
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:39
Frankthetriviaman
you still there TGC?
10:39
TGC Thomas
Just finished Cranky Bugs, it doesn't seem the best of Season 5, but it's still great nonetheless
I'm sort of wondering how Cranky was able to be just put back up like that
Diesel 11 has joined the chat.
10:41
Frankthetriviaman
There's only so much they can show in 4 1/2 minutes; I think a lot happened off screen
I say we should consider it canon
10:41
TGC Thomas
Same here.
10:41
Frankthetriviaman
On to Horrid Lorry then?
10:41
Diesel 11
Hey guys!
10:42
Frankthetriviaman
Hi D-11; TGC and I are watching season 5 episodes
10:42
TGC Thomas
Hey, were just reviewing Season 5 for our canon debate, were on Horrid Lorry now
10:43
Frankthetriviaman
I got it set up on my end, ready to watch. How about you TGC?
10:43
Diesel 11
Interesting. Can't watch them ATM, but I can give my opinion.
10:43
Frankthetriviaman
Thanks D-11; we can always use the extra voice.
Anyway, ready to start TGC?
10:44
Diesel 11
Are you watching this on TinyChat or something together?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
10:44
Frankthetriviaman
No; we are each watching on our own end
He is on mobile though, so he may periodically leave and come.
I'm watching the episode now; give me three minutes to finish it
10:46
Diesel 11
Ah, I see.
Sure.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:47
TGC Thomas
Just finsih
*finshed Horrid Lorry, it's a great episode, I say it should be canon
10:48
Diesel 11
Agreed.
10:48
Frankthetriviaman
Yes, canon indeed
10:49
TGC Thomas
So, on to ABVFG?
10:49
Frankthetriviaman
I think that solves it quick. Better View for Gordon?
Indeed
Got it set up. Ready to go?
10:50
Diesel 11
It's canon.
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
10:55
TGC Thomas
Finished, I'd say it's canon
10:55
Frankthetriviaman
agreed
So on to Lady Hatt's Birthday Party, James and the trouble with trees, and Gordon and the Gremlin
10:56
TGC Thomas
So, we'll move onto Lady Hatt's Birthday Party then I'll have to go for 5 minutes or so, I'll be back quick though.
10:57
Frankthetriviaman
Wait, you mean go for 5 min to watch the video, or do other things?
10:57
TGC Thomas
actually I'll have to go now, it will only be 5 minutes though
10:58
Frankthetriviaman
ok; see you soon
10:58
TGC Thomas
*i have to do some other stuff, I mean
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:01
Diesel 11
See ya.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:02
TGC Thomas
I'm back now, didn't take as long as I though
11:03
Frankthetriviaman
It's ok. I just finished with Lady Hatt's Birthday party; you ready to watch it?
11:03
Diesel 11
It's canon.
11:03
TGC Thomas
Yeah, I'm starting now
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:07
Diesel 11
Oh yeah, before I forget, have you been reading my TUGS fanfics?
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:08
TGC Thomas
It's fairly good, I consider it canon
I mean the episode
11:09
Diesel 11
My TUGS fanfics?
11:09
TGC Thomas
the chat didn't update
i haven't read the fanfics, I'll have too soon.
11:10
Frankthetriviaman
I skimmed them, but still need to read them in depth
11:10
Diesel 11
It's actually the longest stuff I've ever written... I wouldn't mind hearing your thoughts on them.
11:10
TGC Thomas
so, onto the next episode then?
11:11
Frankthetriviaman
yes
*to both.
So, James and the trouble with trees then?
11:11
Diesel 11
Canon.
11:12
Frankthetriviaman
Actually, there is one thing about this episode that kills it for me...
11:12
Diesel 11
What's that?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
11:13
Frankthetriviaman
*I'll tell you when TGC gets back
11:13
Diesel 11
The suspense is killing me.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:16
TGC Thomas
Canon
So, what is the thing that irks you, Frank?
11:17
Frankthetriviaman
How could the train have been too heavy for James to go backwards with? He had no problem pulling it in the first place
11:18
TGC Thomas
He was going downhill.
11:18
Diesel 11
Coupled with the rain, it makes sense to me.
11:18
Frankthetriviaman
I'd buy that. We can consider it canon
11:19
TGC Thomas
Gordon and the gremlin is next up
11:19
Diesel 11
Canon.
:
11:20
Frankthetriviaman
Im ready. How about you?
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:24
TGC Thomas
Finished, Percy's writing wasn't the best in this episode, but still good
11:25
Frankthetriviaman
Major plot hole though
11:25
TGC Thomas
I Didn't see it.
11:25
Frankthetriviaman
So thomas brought the visitor from the docks to Gordon so Gordon could take her...
to Thomas, who then took her to the ferry.
why?
11:26
TGC Thomas
Didn't think of that,
Lets keep it undecided for now, we can have Toz and Tug give their opinions
11:27
Frankthetriviaman
While it was a good story, that for me, makes me want to argue non-canon. But I agree, let's get some other opinions in on this
D-11, you still there?
11:28
Diesel 11
Hold it, let me read the plot summary and I'll weigh in on my thoughts.
*on, not it.
11:28
Frankthetriviaman
Next is Bye George, Baa and Put Upon Percy
11:29
TGC Thomas
non-related to the argument, but that Ferry at the end seems awfully familiar...
I've watched Bye George recently, I say canon
11:29
Diesel 11
Did they say explicitly that she came from the Docks?
11:30
TGC Thomas
Yes.
11:30
Frankthetriviaman
Ah, the Fulton Ferry from Tugs. It was mentioned in Chapter four of the crossover, but I don't think it will play much of a role, to be honesy
*honest
But it is on Sodor, if we change our minds
11:31
Diesel 11
I only watched it a couple times, so I'll need to rewatch it before I give my full thoughts. However...
Perhaps Sir Topham scheduled a 'pleasure trip' on the ferry?
11:32
Frankthetriviaman
Perhaps, but my point, is, why did Thomas bring her from the docks to Gordon at that station, then Gordon brought her to another station, where Thomas picked her up, to take her to the ferry.
Doesn't make much sense
Though yes, Bye George was good, I say canon on that one too
11:33
TGC Thomas
lets go back to this later, I don't need to watch Bye George since I've watched it many times over before and I say canon, I'll wait for Frank though
11:34
Diesel 11
Canon.
11:34
Frankthetriviaman
That's ok, I'm good. Onto Baa! then?
11:34
TGC Thomas
I guess so! BTW I have to get off in half an hour
11:35
Frankthetriviaman
understood.
11:35
Diesel 11
Baa! = Canon.
Sure thing, TGC.
11:35
Frankthetriviaman
Before you go though, I do want to ask you about Thomas and the Tugs, if that is ok TGC
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
TGC Thomas has joined the chat.
11:40
TGC Thomas
Yeah that's fine, we can maybe get 1 more episode in, then talk about other stuff,
so Baa is good, I'll say canon
11:41
Frankthetriviaman
Didn't Percy and Toby seem a little out of character at the beginning though?
11:42
Diesel 11
In Baa! ? I don't think so...
11:42
Frankthetriviaman
"The docks are full of fish, not flowers"... seems kinda mean for Toby
11:42
TGC Thomas
Toby was a little bit OOC, but Percy seemed to be fine, just tired
11:43
Frankthetriviaman
fair point. I want it to be canon, but I didn't like that Toby was OOC
Should we make this one undecided too?
11:44
Diesel 11
*Doesn't know what OOC means* *Looks it up* *Calls himself an idiot*
11:44
TGC Thomas
I'll watch the beginning again real quick
11:45
Diesel 11
And I didn't think he was that OOC.
11:45
TGC Thomas
I think Toby was just teasing Percy a little bit
11:46
Frankthetriviaman
Perhaps. Considering he's not as OOC as other appearances though, I think this is ok then. It's canon
11:47
TGC Thomas
Ok, now I have a quick question, are there any Season 5 Episodes that you are particularly not fond of?
11:48
Diesel 11
Nope. All are great.
11:48
Frankthetriviaman
No, not really
So TGC, about Thomas and the Tugs
11:49
TGC Thomas
im listening
11:49
Frankthetriviaman
You still want to work on the Rosie Puffa Geoffrey arc?
Tug and I haven't touched it, didn't want to risk interfering with your plans
11:50
Diesel 11
Yup, and I can swear for them!
11:51
TGC Thomas
it's fine if you try to do some things with it, for the most part just try to remember stuff from the equivalent arc in 3WSR
11:52
Frankthetriviaman
That's just it... we weren't sure where to go with it.
We were wondering if you wanted to write the next part of it
11:52
TGC Thomas
I'll PM you tomorrow about the arc, gonna have to go off in 10 minutes
11:53
Frankthetriviaman
All right; I look forward to hearing back
The problem has been that i've had a bit of a creative rut with the story; haven't had a new chapter in weeks.
Actually, your help in general would be great
11:54
Diesel 11
If you're in a rut, I might be able to come up with something.
11:54
TGC Thomas
So, let's talk about Seasons 6 and 7, are there any episodes of those that you when problems with? I'm trying to speed up the process by just dealing with episodes that are brought up form problems
11:54
Diesel 11
Involving Nantucket...
11:54
Frankthetriviaman
I have four episodes from season 7 that I don't consider canon
11:55
TGC Thomas
Which 4? And are there any from Season 6 you aren't fond of?
11:55
Frankthetriviaman
D-11: I'm willing to consider it. As long as you don't necessarily contradict what we said in chapter three, it should work
The four episodes are:The Old Bridge .Rheneas and the Roller Coaster .Percy Gets It Right .Edward's Brass Band
11:56
Diesel 11
My thoughts are that they were SOLD as scrap, but something popped up before they WERE scrapped. I'm still working it out in my head, but I think it's a better alternative than just scrapping them.
And why do you consider those non-canon?
11:57
TGC Thomas
Those 4 were pretty bad, I agree with Frank
11:57
Frankthetriviaman
The Old Bridge- Skarloey is way out of character
Roller Coaster- The who plot is ridiculous, and Rheneas is out of character
Percy gets it right- Sir Topham Hatt is out of character
Edward's brass band- out of character Edward
11:58
TGC Thomas
as usual
anyways I have to go now
11:59
Frankthetriviaman
Ok, so we'll see you tomorrow then?
Good night TGC
11:59
Diesel 11
Haven't watched EBB or RATRC, but with TOB, anyone can be scared, even a wise old engine like Skarloey. As for PGIR, sometimes people are just busy.
See you, TGC!
11:59
TGC Thomas
Yeah, PM me if I forget to PM you
12:00
Frankthetriviaman
No problem.
So, D-11, if it'll help, let me just remind you what happened in Thomas and the Tugs
12:01
Diesel 11
Big Mickey and Cranky, right?
12:01
Frankthetriviaman
No, I mean regarding Nantucket
TGC Thomas has left the chat.
12:01
Frankthetriviaman
When the great depression hit, in the following months a lot of older vessels were sold for scrap.
12:01
Diesel 11
Oh, sorry. Sure, go ahead.
12:02
Frankthetriviaman
Old Rusty was sold for scrap because he was a derelect tramper that had just been sitting there for years; there was no saving him
Princess Alice was older than Duchess, Vienna and other cruise ships of the era, so the line that owned her sold her for scrap because she was not worth the upkeep.
And Nantucket was sold for scrap because he was an "old dirt bucket" and his owners decided the cost to maintain him was too much
12:04
Diesel 11
I think I could work with that. I'll see what I can do.
Hi Toz!
12:04
Toz76
What did I miss?
12:04
Diesel 11
Canon discussions.
TGC.
And much, much more!
12:05
Frankthetriviaman
I'll copy and paste this to the live chat PM later
Does that help D-11?